Arbitration ruling
Corporate Institutional Bank of Time v. Kowalczyk-Marchetti
Concerning a dispute over whether interest is owed by the Standard clock or the depositor's own.
The facts
The depositor borrowed 1,648,800 seconds at Foundry Row in 3026 and repaid the loan on the day it fell due. The Bank's clock records the repayment as one second after midnight, and the Bank charged a day's interest on the strength of it. The dispute concerns a dispute over whether interest is owed by the Standard clock or the depositor's own.
A clock brought from another world was installed in the posting room at Svalbard and set to that world's local day, which runs 51 hours longer than the Standard one. Interest was posted for 51 weeks on the strength of it before the difference was noticed.
The arguments
For the claimant it is argued that the credit was made by a clock running ahead of the Standard second, and that a credit of that kind is an error of the Bank's, not a loan the depositor took out.
The clock at Svalbard was inside the tolerance the Clock Standards Board allows. A difference of 51 minutes is the depositor's reading, not a fault in the Bank's records.
Findings
The posting room's clock was 51 minutes fast on the Bank's own sheet for the period in question. Interest posted on its reading is credited back at the Standard rate, and Corporate Institutional Bank of Time v. Eskeland [2669] CIBT Arb 19 fixes the measure.
The day at Svalbard is shorter than the day the depositor's interest is counted in, so one posting was made against two days. I find the Bank posted the wrong day, and the depositor is owed the day the schedule does not give, on the reasoning of Corporate Institutional Bank of Time v. Coldstream [2349] CIBT Arb 4.
Ruling
The fee charged in the old unit is recalculated at the Standard second. Where the old unit was longer, the difference is refunded with interest; where it was shorter, the fee stands, and the Board finds the depositor was not misled.
Yara Achterberg, Arbitrator
Doc. ref. CIBT-3027-099B-2
