Arbitration ruling
Corporate Institutional Bank of Time v. Oyelaran
Concerning a rate fixed by a joint form signed on the afternoon of a wedding.

The facts
A joint account at Ring Road was closed by letter in 3027. The letter was signed in one holder's name and countersigned in the other's. The second holder says she was in another city that month, and the countersignature appears on a form that was not printed until the following year. A rate fixed by a joint form signed on the afternoon of a wedding is the matter before the Board.
A wedding gift of 1,108,800 seconds was paid into a trust at Luna for a bride, and drawn on by the groom the following year. The trust deed required two trustees' signatures, and only one trustee's name appears on the withdrawal. The second trustee says he signed a blank form in 3027 at the request of a clerk he did not know.
The arguments
A letter from one holder cannot end a joint account, and the claimant says the Bank's notice of separation in 3027 bore one name only. The account remained joint in law until both signatures were on the paper, and the Bank has no second signature to produce.
The Bank submits that a joint account may be drawn on by either holder until both have signed it closed. A letter asking for the account to be divided is not that signature, however fairly it is put. The Bank sent the division form in 3027, and the form was never returned. Until then the account stood as the holders opened it, and the copy of the letter was kept under a paperweight that was once a clock's face.
Findings
Both holders signed the opening form in 3006. The form contains no clause on separation, so the Board looks to the Bank's practice, which is to hold a joint balance until both names agree to its division.
A joint balance cannot be taken by one holder alone while the account stands in two names. The move to Luna was made without the second signature, and the 1,108,800 seconds return to the account, on the reasoning of Szabo v. Corporate Institutional Bank of Time [1775] CIBT Arb 5.
Ruling
The countersignature on the joint form is declared to have been added after the second holder left Luna. The Bank will not treat the withdrawal it supported as valid, and will restore the sum to the joint account.
Folke Gunnarsdottir, Arbitrator
Doc. ref. CIBT-3027-A4E2-0