Arbitration ruling · Appeal Panel
Galloway v. Corporate Institutional Bank of Time (on appeal)
An appeal brought by Faro Galloway against the award below and the order for costs.
Background
A deposit of 30 Standard days was booked as sent from Hill Station on the morning of its dispatch, and the receiving branch has no entry for it at all. The sending clerk's copy and the receiving clerk's copy bear different signatures. The claimant says the receiving counter was shut that morning. The Bank says it was open. The dispute concerns a signature the claimant says was added after the transaction it supports.
The arbitrator below applied Zelenko v. Corporate Institutional Bank of Time [3024] CIBT Arb 3.
Grounds of appeal
- That the arbitrator put the burden on the appellant to prove the signature genuine, although the Bank produced neither the card the teller compared it with nor any note of which card that was.
- That the arbitrator costed the ledger's column as a total of the receipts, although the column had been totalled by a hand that never handled the counterfoils.
- That the arbitrator divided the estate's seconds between the claimant and a cousin who never lodged a claim in these proceedings.
- That the arbitrator recognised the claimant as the holder's sole heir on the strength of a family entry written in a different hand from the rest of the register, and did not ask who had made it.
The Bank's answer
A son who was never a holder of record has no claim on the balance. The Bank's records name the two holders as they stood in 2862. A third name written in pencil in the margin is not a signature.
Decision of the Panel
The appellant asks the Panel to prefer the receipt because it is in the teller's own hand. A signature shows that the teller took the money; it does not show where it was entered. The ledger shows what was entered, and the award rightly rests on it.
Appeal dismissed. The award below is confirmed in full.
Signed
Kaito Drummond · Kesi Quigley-Achterberg · Esme Valderrama
Doc. ref. CIBT-3027-96E9-1
