Arbitration ruling
Inglewood v. Corporate Institutional Bank of Time
Concerning a codicil leaving a balance of hours to a branch rather than to a person.
The facts
The depositor died in 2963, leaving her hours to three heirs who could not agree which of them was the eldest. The hours were held at the Heights Branch until the estate was confirmed. In 3027 the heirs asked for the transfer, and a dispute arose over a codicil leaving a balance of hours to a branch rather than to a person.
The estate of a depositor who died in 3027 included an unspent balance of hours at the Heights Branch. The beneficiary says the withholding was unlawful.
The arguments
The estate's hours were held for three children together, and a will that divides a balance among three cannot be read to give the whole to the eldest. The claimant asks that the shares be paid in the proportions the will gives, with no deduction for the trustee's trouble.
The Bank does not measure heirs. A bequest that turns on height cannot be carried out by a counter, and the Board is asked to say which grandson the will meant. Until it does, the hours stay where they were deposited, which is the one thing the Bank can always do.
Findings
Interest that accrued on an estate's hours during the years the executor was missing belongs to the estate, not to the first heir who reaches the counter. Corporate Institutional Bank of Time v. Ravensworth [1918] CIBT Arb 9 is plain that a dead depositor's interest is held for the heirs together, and the claim is no weaker for a pocket watch that stopped at the hour of a funeral that one heir happens to hold.
The trust deed names no heir and no executor. I find that the hours were held for the heirs jointly, and that moving them without all three signatures was outside the Bank's authority, on the reasoning of Corporate Institutional Bank of Time v. Whitlock [2807] CIBT Arb 2.
Ruling
The claim is allowed in part. The estate's hours are held until all three heirs have signed the division, and the Board has heard a neighbour who was sure of the day and less sure of the year.
Bodhi Yardley, Arbitrator
Doc. ref. CIBT-3027-6601-9
