Arbitration ruling · Appeal Panel
Corporate Institutional Bank of Time v. Coldstream-Grisolm (on appeal)
An appeal brought by Emeka Coldstream-Grisolm against the award below.
Background
A transfer slip for 1,029,600 seconds was presented at the Dockside Branch in 3026. The signature on it differs from the card on file. The holder, a veteran with a mechanical right wrist, says it was signed with the wrist's actuator a week after a fitting. The teller compared the two and paid the withdrawal in full. The dispute is about a teller's initials on a transfer the teller says were not hers.
The arbitrator below followed Fothergill-Mbatha v. Corporate Institutional Bank of Time [3025] CIBT Arb 21.
Grounds of appeal
- That the arbitrator equated the teller's initials on the slip with a comparison of the signature, when the initials show only that the slip was received at the window.
- That the arbitrator concluded the depositor had signed the second form, because the teller said nothing at the window, although a teller's silence is not a comparison of the signature.
The Bank's answer
The heirs took their shares under a single transfer order, and the Bank's duty was to carry that order out. Nothing in the terms makes the Bank answerable for dividing an estate it was asked only to hold, and the Bank did not undertake to decide which child came first.
Decision of the Panel
The appellant asks the Panel to treat the receipt as conclusive because it is in the teller's own hand. A signature shows that the teller received the money; it does not show that it was entered at all. The ledger shows what was entered, and the award is right to rest on it.
Appeal dismissed. The award below stands.
Signed
Ulla Hightower · Isolde Northcott · Kaito Fennimore
Doc. ref. CIBT-3028-480E-0
