Arbitration ruling
Corporate Institutional Bank of Time v. Ostrander
Concerning the disappearance of a sealed consignment between two branches on one world.

The facts
A consignment of 1,134,000 seconds was lost between two branches on the same world. It was insured under a Turbulence Cover policy, which the insurer says lapsed when the consignment was handed over, not when it was dispatched. The Bank says both happened on the same morning, and the question is the disappearance of a sealed consignment between two branches on one world.
A sealed deposit of 1,134,000 seconds was lodged at the Ring Road Branch for delivery to Ganymede. The receipt was signed, but the consignment did not arrive, and no one at the receiving branch recalls signing for it. The parties agree on the sealing and disagree about the handover.
The arguments
The sealed bag was signed for at Ring Road and the receipt was stamped. The Bank's courier has no record of a second stop, so whatever happened to the deposit happened inside the Bank's own custody, and the Bank must trace it.
The Bank produced the courier's signed receipt for the sealed case. The blank line in the receiving register is a matter for the receiving desk, the Bank submits, and the case was delivered at the point the terms make delivery.
Findings
A policy's cover runs from the moment a consignment is handed over. Where dispatch and handover fall on the same morning, the policy is in force for both, and the insurer must answer for the loss, as Rasmussen v. Corporate Institutional Bank of Time [1840] CIBT Arb 1 explains.
A sealed case handed to a courier who signed the manifest but not the receiving docket has not been shown to be delivered. I find the Bank answers for the 1,134,000 seconds it carried, as Larkspur v. Corporate Institutional Bank of Time [1911] CIBT Arb 8 holds.
Ruling
The claimant's costs of 1,134,000 seconds are paid by the Bank, since the case was sealed in its own bag and the Bank cannot say where it went. The receiving clerk is to be told in writing that a signed case stays the Bank's until it is opened.
Bodhi Voss, Arbitrator
Doc. ref. CIBT-3028-4BE8-8