Arbitration ruling · Appeal Panel
Underhill-Zelenko v. Corporate Institutional Bank of Time (on appeal)
Appeal brought by Esme Underhill-Zelenko against the award below.

Background
The courier's seal was intact when the bag left Montréal Sector and broken when it reached the Polar Vault Branch, 23 Standard days later. The Bank has been asked to consider a courier's manifest with a page missing.
The arbitrator below followed Castellane v. Corporate Institutional Bank of Time [3027] CIBT Arb 28.
Grounds of appeal
- That the arbitrator treated the passbook entry for 475,200 seconds as conclusive, though the page showed signs of re-gluing and the teller who initialled it was never called.
- That the arbitrator tallied the drawer at 475,200 seconds short, although the drawer had been short since the start of the week and the sheet recorded no coin going missing on the day.
- That the arbitrator equated the ledger's closing total with the day's deposits, although the total had been brought down from a page the clerk had not yet signed.
The Bank's answer
The Authority's order on published fees was complied with at the branch in 3026, and the notice was posted at the counter in the form the order requires. A fee the notice describes is not a fee the Bank can be asked to explain again.
Decision of the Panel
The appellant asks the Panel to treat the receipt as conclusive because it is signed by the teller. A signature shows that the teller received the money; it does not show that it was entered at all. The ledger shows the entry, and the award is right to rest on it.
The drawer at Montréal Sector was shut with a hessian bag stuffed into the slot on the day of the deposit, and the appellant says that is why the sum was short. A drawer that would not lock proves nothing about the sum in it, and the arbitrator was right to look at the till sheet first. It is dismissed.
Appeal dismissed. The award below stands in full.
Dissent
A silent relay refuses nothing. The relay to Montréal Sector was silent for 23 hours, and the award reads that silence as a refusal, so I would have allowed the appeal on that footing alone.
Zeno Grisolm, dissenting
Signed
Uma Fennimore · Calla Valderrama · Zeno Grisolm
Doc. ref. CIBT-3028-46E5-3