Montréal Sector18:24:33
Mars StationSol 410,894 08:49:41
The Belt7.59.17
Titan AnnexBeat 369.04
Corporate InstitutionalBank of Time0001
Alien delegates in tiers, one bank officer presenting at the centre

Legal › 3029 › Corporate Institutional Bank of Time v. Achterberg

Arbitration ruling

Corporate Institutional Bank of Time v. Achterberg

Citation
[3029] CIBT Arb 8
Claimant
Wren Achterberg
Arbitrator
Juno Fennimore-Nakashima

Concerning an estate's hours released by a branch that had not been told the executor had died against a silver card case that came with the house and not with the family.

Alien delegates in tiers, one bank officer presenting at the centre
Plate I Alien delegates in tiers, one bank officer presenting at the centre. From the Bank's archive.

The facts

The estate of a depositor who died in 3028 included an unspent balance of hours at the Polar Vault Branch. The executor paid one beneficiary and withheld the rest pending an estate's hours released by a branch that had not been told the executor had died against a silver card case that came with the house and not with the family. The beneficiary says the withholding was unlawful.

The depositor died in 2856, leaving her hours to three heirs who could not agree which of them was the eldest. The hours were held at the Polar Vault Branch until the estate was confirmed.

The arguments

The estate's hours were held for three children together, and a will that divides a balance among three cannot be read to give the whole to the eldest. The claimant asks that the shares be paid in the proportions the will gives, with no deduction for the trustee's trouble.

A proxy card remains good until the Bank is told its holder has died, the Bank submits, and it was never told. The estate was closed in order on that card, however the proxy came to die afterwards.

Findings

Hours in an estate are paid to the heir the Board has confirmed, and to no other. A payment made on a grant that was later amended cannot stand against the grant that replaces it, as Ravensworth v. Corporate Institutional Bank of Time [1795] CIBT Arb 1 decided.

Interest that accrued on an estate's hours during the years the executor was missing belongs to the estate, not to the first heir who reaches the counter. Hightower v. Corporate Institutional Bank of Time [1727] CIBT Arb 26 is plain that a dead depositor's interest is held for the heirs together, and the claim is no weaker for a music box that plays one tune and then stops that one heir happens to hold.

Ruling

The estate is divided under the will. A lodger who still owes rent is not entitled to the hours until the rent is paid, so the Board orders the arrears set against his share and the balance paid to the heirs.

Juno Fennimore-Nakashima, Arbitrator

Doc. ref. CIBT-3029-119A-6