Montréal Sector18:24:31
Mars StationSol 410,894 08:49:40
The Belt7.59.11
Titan AnnexBeat 369.04
Corporate InstitutionalBank of Time0001
Alien delegates in tiers, one bank officer presenting at the centre

Legal › 3029 › Corporate Institutional Bank of Time v. Wetherby-Thistlewood (on appeal)

Arbitration ruling · Appeal Panel

Corporate Institutional Bank of Time v. Wetherby-Thistlewood (on appeal)

Citation
[3029] CIBT Arb 6 (Appeal)
Appellant
Nils Wetherby-Thistlewood
Panel
Xan Juvonen (presiding), Jarrah Jaramillo-Mbatha, Oren Ostrander
On appeal from
Award of Bodhi Drummond-Coldstream, November 3028

Appeal brought by Nils Wetherby-Thistlewood against the award below.

Alien delegates in tiers, one bank officer presenting at the centre
Plate I Alien delegates in tiers, one bank officer presenting at the centre. From the Bank's archive.

Background

Since 2937 the claimant has banked at the Grand Concourse Branch. A dispute arose in 3028 over a deposit tendered by a tenant on a landlord's behalf and never credited to the landlord. For a period the reconciliation hall later measured, the claimant's deposit was credited with interest on the strength of a branch clock that the hall found to be running fast.

Bodhi Drummond-Coldstream, the arbitrator below, relied on Quigley v. Corporate Institutional Bank of Time [3028] CIBT Arb 15.

Grounds of appeal

  1. That the 1,029,600 seconds found in the loose drawer at Grand Concourse were counted as the appellant's deposit, when the drawer had never been locked and the count was not taken until the day after the close.
  2. That the signature on the deposit was not compared with the specimen card held at Grand Concourse, and the teller's note that the two did not agree was never put to the appellant.
  3. That the Bank's own tally showed the clock at Europa running fast by 1,029,600 seconds, and the arbitrator never asked which clock had been used for the deposit.
  4. That the arbitrator held that a receipt for 1,029,600 seconds with no ledger line was no deposit at all, without asking the teller where the money went.

The Bank's answer

The joint balance was divided on the shares the ledger records, and those shares were set when the account was opened. The Bank divides by the ledger, not by the household as it stood on any later day.

Decision of the Panel

The receipt was written at the counter, at the moment of payment. The ledger line was made later, at the close of the day, by a clerk who was not at the window. Where the two differ, the arbitrator should have asked which of them was made first.

Order of the Panel

The appeal succeeds in part. The award of 1,087,200 seconds is varied to 1,728,648 seconds.

Signed

Xan Juvonen · Jarrah Jaramillo-Mbatha · Oren Ostrander

Doc. ref. CIBT-3029-BC21-8