Montréal Sector18:24:35
Mars StationSol 410,894 08:49:43
The Belt7.59.23
Titan AnnexBeat 369.04
Corporate InstitutionalBank of Time0001
Alien delegates in tiers, one bank officer presenting at the centre

Legal › 3029 › Fothergill v. Corporate Institutional Bank of Time (on appeal)

Arbitration ruling · Appeal Panel

Fothergill v. Corporate Institutional Bank of Time (on appeal)

Citation
[3029] CIBT Arb 2 (Appeal)
Appellant
Yara Fothergill
Panel
Rafe Hightower (presiding), Ivo Drummond, Faro Fothergill
On appeal from
Award of Quill Mbatha-Halloran, September 3028

An appeal by the depositor against the arbitrator's award.

Alien delegates in tiers, one bank officer presenting at the centre
Plate I Alien delegates in tiers, one bank officer presenting at the centre. From the Bank's archive.

Background

An employer's clerk sent the same payroll to the Ring Road Branch twice in 3028, and both batches were credited. The employer then asked the Bank to recover the second batch from the staff's next wages. The Bank's payroll service did so without notice, as a door banged twice in the draught from the street. The staff say the duplicate was never theirs to repay. The claim concerns a credit for wages posted before the employer's payroll was sent.

Quill Mbatha-Halloran, the arbitrator below, relied on Corporate Institutional Bank of Time v. Ravensworth [3028] CIBT Arb 4, as arbitrators usually do.

Grounds of appeal

  1. That the arbitrator booked each of the 17 relay copies as a separate transfer, although the relay had sent every message twice and the duplicates were never posted at either branch.
  2. That the arbitrator found the transfer posted on the day the relay was down, when the relay log the Bank produced shows the message held in the queue and never sent.
  3. That the arbitrator fixed the depositor's intent from one letter, though the depositor says the letter was written on the stub of a cancelled journey and never sent.

The Bank's answer

The notice was typed by the branch from its own copy of the form, and the Bank is not answerable for a branch's copy of its own form. The notice went to the last address on file, which was the claimant's.

Decision of the Panel

A message the relay sent twice is paid once. The second copy was never posted at either end, and the Bank's log shows it. The appellant was not charged twice. The point fails.

Order of the Panel

Appeal dismissed. The award below stands.

Signed

Rafe Hightower · Ivo Drummond · Faro Fothergill

Doc. ref. CIBT-3029-87BD-1