Arbitration ruling
Corporate Institutional Bank of Time v. Delacroix-Mbeki
Concerning a joint account held by two depositors who no longer share a branch.

The facts
The depositor's estate was confirmed in 3027, and her executors asked for the share held in the joint account by the other holder to be paid over. The other holder had died two years earlier, and her share had stayed in the account in both names. The executors say the Bank had no authority to keep it there, and that the dispute concerns a joint account held by two depositors who no longer share a branch.
A mother and her son held a joint account at the Dockside Branch for his schooling, to pass to him at his majority. When the mother remarried in 3027, the son asked for the account to be put in his name alone. The counter told him the account could not be changed while both holders lived, and the mother went on drawing on it.
The arguments
Her partnership ended in 3027, and the freeze she asked the Bank for went into a tray and was never keyed. The joint account was left open for both names as if nothing had been asked, and the claimant asks the Bank to answer for the sums that moved in the weeks that followed.
A joint account is drawn in the names on it, and the counter pays whichever holder presents a valid form. The Bank was not told that the partnership had ended until 27 years after it did, and it was bound to act on the form it held.
Findings
The shares of a joint account are fixed by what each holder paid in, and not by the number of names on the form. On the reasoning of Quigley-Xiomara v. Corporate Institutional Bank of Time [2361] CIBT Arb 8, a split by headcount misstates both shares, and the ledger must be corrected.
Interest posted to a joint account in the first holder's name alone, after both holders had signed the separation, is not a withdrawal. It moved the second holder's share to the first, however, and I find the posting must be reversed, as Corporate Institutional Bank of Time v. Marchetti-Achterberg [1424] CIBT Arb 18 requires.
Ruling
Each holder's share is confirmed as shown on the ledger page of 2893. The Bank will not release any part of the account while the holders remain in dispute.
Hamid Blackwood, Arbitrator
Doc. ref. CIBT-3027-000F-8