Montréal Sector18:24:34
Mars StationSol 410,894 08:49:43
The Belt7.59.20
Titan AnnexBeat 369.04
Corporate InstitutionalBank of Time0001
A lone arbitrator at a curved bench beneath a window of stars

Legal › 3027 › Corporate Institutional Bank of Time v. Achterberg (on appeal)

Arbitration ruling · Appeal Panel

Corporate Institutional Bank of Time v. Achterberg (on appeal)

Citation
[3027] CIBT Arb 21 (Appeal)
Appellant
Ama Achterberg
Panel
Juno Galloway (presiding), Isolde Okonkwo, Caio Dunmore
On appeal from
Award of Dagny Grisolm-Gunnarsdottir, November 3027

An appeal by the depositor against the arbitrator's award and the order for costs.

A lone arbitrator at a curved bench beneath a window of stars
Plate I A lone arbitrator at a curved bench beneath a window of stars. From the Bank's archive.

Background

An heir to a share of hours declined to sign the transfer, and the Bank moved the share anyway on a notice the heir had not read. The notice was posted to Polar Vault, and the heir lives on another world. The claim concerns hours sent by courier to an heir who had moved house and left no forwarding address.

The arbitrator below relied on Juvonen v. Corporate Institutional Bank of Time [3025] CIBT Arb 20, and the appeal turns largely on whether that ruling governs this one.

Grounds of appeal

  1. That the arbitrator dismissed the heir's claim as out of time, on the strength of a notice sent to a former address.
  2. That the arbitrator marked the claimant late for the counter because the clock above the window had stood at 37 minutes past the hour since the Tuesday, without asking who had left it stopped.
  3. That the arbitrator took a withdrawal that the relay had held for 37 hours as made on the day it was keyed, although the queue rule dates a held message to the hour it was first sent.
  4. That the arbitrator left the second heir off the division of 129,600 seconds because her name stood in pencil on the register, and did not ask whether the pencil had been rubbed by a clerk after 3025.

The Bank's answer

The Bank was not sent any instruction to freeze the account, only a letter, and the terms require a signed form for a freeze. The posting was made on the ledger line that the holders had both agreed to keep, and the Bank argues that it is the holders' task to say which line is theirs.

Decision of the Panel

The appellant argues the claim was made in time because a letter was sent. A letter sent to a former address is not notice, and the award was right to say so.

The depositor insisted that the first slip had been left in a folded map of the district, and came back the next morning to say so. The counter stamped the slip on the first visit, and the stamp stands whether or not the slip was ever collected. Nothing was paid on the second visit, and the appellant has shown no deposit made on it. The point fails.

Order of the Panel

Appeal dismissed. The award below is confirmed in full.

Signed

Juno Galloway · Isolde Okonkwo · Caio Dunmore

Doc. ref. CIBT-3027-38E5-3