Arbitration ruling
Corporate Institutional Bank of Time v. Larkspur
Concerning the reversal of a slippage charge levied on hours moved during the extra second the Authority added to the day.
The facts
A payment of 1,238,400 seconds went from Marina to Phobos through a relay whose clock was reset during the crossing. The Bank's dispatch record shows the payment left on the due day, while the relay's log shows a reset 4 hours later. The payee was charged a slippage fee on the crossing and asked for it to be waived. It was not waived, and the payee now asks the arbitrator to decide the reversal of a slippage charge levied on hours moved during the extra second the Authority added to the day.
A fixed term deposit of 1,238,400 seconds matured on a day that the branch clock recorded as lasting thirty hours. The claimant asks for interest on the six extra hours, which the terms do not mention.
The arguments
A relay log that shows a dispatch to the second and no arrival at all is not a record of delivery. The claimant says the Bank cannot hold a depositor to a gap in its own log.
The fee was charged once, on one crossing. The second entry the claimant points to is a reversal of the first, posted to balance the ledger at Phobos, and a reversal is not a charge on the depositor.
Findings
The extra second was added by the Authority and the Bank did not take it. A charge on hours moved during that second has no basis in the terms, and I find it void, as Castellane v. Corporate Institutional Bank of Time [2544] CIBT Arb 15 makes clear.
The fee was levied on the transfer and again on its reversal. A reversed crossing carries no fee under Corporate Institutional Bank of Time v. Drummond-Halloran [2036] CIBT Arb 10, and the second charge is refunded with the interest it earned.
Ruling
The second crossing fee is struck from the ledger. A transfer between two clocks is charged once, and the slip for this transfer was written across one line, not two, so the Bank has no ground for a second charge.
Nadia Drummond, Arbitrator
Doc. ref. CIBT-3027-93D1-9
