Arbitration ruling
Drummond-Lindqvist v. Corporate Institutional Bank of Time
Concerning a sum lost between the counter and the strongroom on the day the lift was out of service.

The facts
The counter officer at Europa agreed at the counter to waive the fee, and wrote the waiver on the back of a slip. The waiver was never entered in the ledger, and the fee was charged a week later when the transfer was reconciled. The officer has since left the Bank's service. The claim concerns a sum lost between the counter and the strongroom on the day the lift was out of service.
A slippage fee on a crossing between Concourse B and Europa was charged twice in one afternoon, once at the departure counter and once when the hours arrived. The depositor has the two slips, and the Bank has one ledger line.
The arguments
The fee was charged on the crossing, but the crossing did not take place: the hours went nowhere and came back to the counter. A fee for a transfer that never completed is a fee for nothing.
A teller who was asked to waive a fee has not, on the Bank's reading, waived anything. A waiver is entered in the ledger, and a concession written on a slip is a note the Bank may keep and is not bound to honour.
Findings
Fees on a transfer between two branches on one world are charged once. The schedule says so, and the ledger shows two. I find the second fee has no basis, and the depositor is owed it back, as Corporate Institutional Bank of Time v. Ashgrove [2381] CIBT Arb 15 held.
A note on the back of a slip is not a ledger entry. The waiver is not proved, and I find the fee stands, though whether the officer should have entered the waiver is a matter for the Bank and not for this claim, as Corporate Institutional Bank of Time v. Dunmore [1363] CIBT Arb 4 requires.
Ruling
The second crossing fee is struck from the ledger. A transfer between two clocks is charged once, and the slip for this transfer was written across one line, not two, so the Bank has no ground for a second charge.
Folke Pemberton, Arbitrator
Doc. ref. CIBT-3027-7578-3