Arbitration ruling
Corporate Institutional Bank of Time v. Quaresma
Concerning a slippage fee on a crossing made during the branch's closing hour.
The facts
A payment of 1,335,600 seconds went from Old Town to Io through a relay whose clock was reset during the crossing. The Bank's dispatch record shows the payment left on the due day, while the relay's log shows a reset 13 hours later. The payee was charged a slippage fee on the crossing and asked for it to be waived. It was not waived, and the payee now asks the arbitrator to decide a slippage fee on a crossing made during the branch's closing hour.
The claimant asked for a transfer to Io to be cancelled at the counter, before any hours had left the branch. The teller agreed and tore up the slip, but the reconciliation hall charged the slippage fee on the crossing all the same. The claimant was told that the fee follows the instruction and not the hours.
The arguments
A cancellation received before a transfer leaves should have some effect on the fee. The claimant cancelled in the same minute the hours were dispatched, and a bank that can record a dispatch to the second can record a cancellation to the same second.
Clock-fitters work while the branch is open, and the Bank's staff do not stop a clock for a lunch hour. The transfer was made while the clock was at rest, which the Bank records as a crossing with no slippage, and no slippage was charged.
Findings
A cancelled transfer is a transfer that has not left, and a fee charged on it after cancellation is not owed. The minute between cancellation and dispatch does not decide the matter, as Hightower v. Corporate Institutional Bank of Time [1333] CIBT Arb 3 explains.
A slippage fee is charged for crossing a clock boundary, not for carrying a message. The reconciliation hall's own report records both branches reading the same second, so there was no crossing to charge for.
Ruling
The matter is referred to the reconciliation hall, which will trace the consignment through the relay's own log. The claimant is to be told the result within 13 months.
Juno Pemberton, Arbitrator
Doc. ref. CIBT-3027-0B64-4
