Montréal Sector18:24:33
Mars StationSol 410,894 08:49:42
The Belt7.59.17
Titan AnnexBeat 369.04
Corporate InstitutionalBank of Time0001
Alien delegates in tiers, one bank officer presenting at the centre

Legal › 3027 › Galloway v. Corporate Institutional Bank of Time

Arbitration ruling

Galloway v. Corporate Institutional Bank of Time

Citation
[3027] CIBT Arb 18
Claimant
Odile Galloway
Arbitrator
Dario Quigley

Concerning a dormant account whose named beneficiary was a dog, and whether a dog may hold a balance.

Alien delegates in tiers, one bank officer presenting at the centre
Plate I Alien delegates in tiers, one bank officer presenting at the centre. From the Bank's archive.

The facts

The clerk noted that a beneficiary must be a person to hold a balance, and asked the neighbour to name the person the account should go to. The neighbour says the dog is a person in every way that matters to the account. The matter is a dormant account whose named beneficiary was a dog, and whether a dog may hold a balance.

The joint account was opened in 3002 in the names of two holders. In 3027 one holder wrote to the Concourse B Branch to say that the holders had separated, and asked the Bank to hold the balance until the position was settled. The other holder drew 334,800 seconds on the same day.

The arguments

The Bank owes a second check to any holder whose new account is opened in a name the holder has never used. The claimant says none was made, and that the first check was made by the same clerk who opened it.

A dog cannot hold a deposit, and the terms name a holder who is a person. The Bank holds the balance for the person whose name is on the account. A dog's name on a beneficiary form is not a valid nomination.

Findings

Separation without a notice of separation does not end a joint account. Until both holders have signed to that effect, each may draw on it, but a holder who has been asked in writing to stop by the other has no right to draw in the other's absence, as Corporate Institutional Bank of Time v. Yeboah [2630] CIBT Arb 15 decided.

A joint account stands as it was opened until the Bank is told otherwise in writing. A withdrawal made after the other holder asked in writing for a freeze was not properly made, and the balance goes back, following Dunmore v. Corporate Institutional Bank of Time [2929] CIBT Arb 9.

Ruling

For the purposes of interest the account is to be treated as joint, the second name having lain unanswered in the file since 3002. The Bank will pay the interest in equal shares and hold the second share until its owner gives an address.

Dario Quigley, Arbitrator

Doc. ref. CIBT-3027-6F9E-4