Montréal Sector18:24:33
Mars StationSol 410,894 08:49:41
The Belt7.59.17
Titan AnnexBeat 369.04
Corporate InstitutionalBank of Time0001
A lone arbitrator at a curved bench beneath a window of stars

Legal › 3028 › Fairbrass v. Corporate Institutional Bank of Time (on appeal)

Arbitration ruling · Appeal Panel

Fairbrass v. Corporate Institutional Bank of Time (on appeal)

Citation
[3028] CIBT Arb 13 (Appeal)
Appellant
Calla Fairbrass
Panel
Odile Yeboah (presiding), Kofi Abernethy, Uma Oyelaran
On appeal from
Award of Emeka Delacroix-Mbeki, June 3028

An appeal brought by Calla Fairbrass against the arbitrator's award.

A lone arbitrator at a curved bench beneath a window of stars
Plate I A lone arbitrator at a curved bench beneath a window of stars. From the Bank's archive.

Background

For 12 years the holder of a dormant account at L4 Habitat made no withdrawal and gave no instruction. Interest was posted each quarter at the dormant rate. The holder's executor came to the counter in 3027 and asked for the balance, and for an explanation of interest on a bond posted to a dormant holder's account after death.

The arbitrator below relied on Corporate Institutional Bank of Time v. Halloran [3027] CIBT Arb 19.

Grounds of appeal

  1. That the arbitrator construed the letters CR on the advice slip as a credit to the appellant, although at L4 Habitat they stood for another holder's account.
  2. That the arbitrator decided the holder's capacity to open an account by judging age from a family photograph, although the birth entry lodged at Paulista settles the date of birth.
  3. That the arbitrator ran interest on the disputed sum from the day the drawer was first reported, though the report mentions no sum and the drawer was not checked again for 12 days.
  4. That the arbitrator booked each of the 12 relay copies as a separate transfer, although the relay had sent every message twice and the duplicates were never posted at either branch.

The Bank's answer

The teller compared the signature with the card and recorded the match at the time. Under the terms the check is the teller's, and the teller made it.

Decision of the Panel

A message the relay sent twice is paid once. The Bank's log shows that the second copy was never posted at either end. Nothing was charged to the appellant twice. The point fails.

Order of the Panel

Appeal dismissed. The award below is confirmed.

Signed

Odile Yeboah · Kofi Abernethy · Uma Oyelaran

Doc. ref. CIBT-3028-E24A-1