Arbitration ruling
Oyelaran v. Corporate Institutional Bank of Time
Concerning interest posted on a sunrise that the station clock recorded as early by most of a shift.
The facts
A clock at the Canal Street posting room was replaced in 3026 with one brought from another branch, which was set to a different local day. Interest for the period was posted on the old clock's reading, and the dispute concerns interest posted on a sunrise that the station clock recorded as early by most of a shift.
A fixed term deposit of 219,600 seconds matured on a day that the branch clock recorded as lasting thirty hours. The claimant asks for interest on the six extra hours, which the terms do not mention.
The arguments
The Authority sets the reference second, and the branch clock is a different matter. The Bank posted interest by its own clock, the claimant argues, and is bound by the readings it printed on the statements.
A claim under these terms must be brought within a fixed period from the event. That period ended long before the claimant came to the counter, and the Bank asks that the claim be dismissed on that ground alone.
Findings
The posting room's clock was 49 minutes fast on the Bank's own sheet for the period in question. Interest posted on its reading is credited back at the Standard rate, and Fairbrass-Marchetti v. Corporate Institutional Bank of Time [1879] CIBT Arb 11 fixes the measure.
A box is held on the terms of its deposit, not on the reading of the clock inside it. The clock stopped, but the hours did not, and the Bank owes the balance it recorded.
Ruling
Interest on the dormant balance is owed for the whole of the period in dispute. The holder is to receive 219,600 seconds, worked at the rate in force in each year, posted within 49 Standard days.
Jarrah Fennimore, Arbitrator
Doc. ref. CIBT-3028-88FD-5
